Ten Questions for Bonnie Jo Campbell

by Staff
10.13.26

This week’s installment of Ten Questions features Bonnie Jo Campbell, whose novel The Spirits is out today from W. W. Norton. The novel, a contemporary take on Dickens’s Christmas Carol (Chapman & Hall, 1943), opens on the morning before Christmas. A young woman in Paw Paw, Michigan, has woken up early to go visit her father’s grave. “This morning before dawn, she had gotten on her hands and knees and exhaled on the stone to melt a bit of ice before laying across its surface a fresh-cut pine bough with soft blue-green needles—a peace offering. ‘Merry Christmas, Daddy,’ she said now, in the direction of his grave. ‘I’m sorry, so please, leave me the hell alone tonight.’” But when her brother Doug unexpectedly brings his girlfriend Mary home for the holidays, long-held secrets come to the surface and old ghosts emerge. In a starred review, Booklist calls Campbell’s prose “rapturous and darn near Shakespearean as she conjures storms of vengeance and grief that give way to the radiance of truth and love.” And in Library Journal, M. Tiffany Messer-Bass adds that “this atmospheric novel captivates with its slow-burning exploration of grief, family, and redemption.” Bonnie Jo Campbell is the author of novels including The Waters (Norton, 2024), Once Upon a River (Norton, 2011), and Q Road (Scribner, 2002). She has also written the short story collections American Salvage (Norton, 2009), which was a finalist for the National Book Award and the National Book Critics Circle Award; Women and Other Animals (University of Massachusetts Press, 1999), which won the AWP Grace Paley Prize; and Mothers, Tell Your Daughters (Norton, 2015). She was a Guggenheim fellow in 2011 and has also received the Eudora Welty Prize and the Mark Twain Award. She lives outside of Kalamazoo on a small farm with her husband and donkeys.

Bonnie Jo Campbell, author of The Spirits.   (Credit: Fran Dwight)

1. How long did it take you to write The Spirits?
I’ve been telling people this novel took me only about a year and a half [compared to] the decade it took to write The Waters, but that’s a lie. Sort of. Many moons ago (a decade?) I wrote a very long short story called “The Holly & The Ivy,” about a Christmas Eve family dinner. I messed around with it for about a year before putting it aside. So maybe The Spirits took me eighteen months...or maybe, if you consider how long this story was kicking around in the back of my head, it took a heck of a lot longer. 

2. What was the most challenging thing about writing the book?
Every time I start a new project, I tell myself that this time I’ll crack the code to the story universe, my brain-clouds will part, and a novel will pour out of me like sunshine and blue sky, but each time there’s some profound new challenge. After working on The Spirits feverishly for about six months, I got acid reflux and had to give up tomatoes, onions, and coffee—writing without coffee was a challenge!

Content-wise, maybe the hardest thing for me, a realist writer, was to incorporate a ghost into the work. Because I’m personally skeptical regarding all things supernatural, I hesitated to allow a ghost into the room. Or rather, I refused to see the ghost that was already in the room! But in the time between writing the story and turning it into a novel, I’ve come to appreciate how powerful the phenomenon of psychological projection is. We all have blind spots, and we can’t see aspects of ourselves, and so these characteristics get projected out into the world, often attributed to other people—we see this when family members are scapegoated and in our feelings about political figures. Sometimes this unacceptable stuff inside us has nowhere else to go, and so it becomes a ghost. The good news for a writer struggling to make a ghost seem plausible comes straight from Shakespeare—turns out it doesn’t matter if we imagine Banquo’s ghost is actual ectoplasm or a psychological manifestation. If we write it well, it works either way! Now I’m overjoyed to have a new fictional element to work with. I don’t think I’m done with writing ghosts. 

3. Where, when, and how often do you write?
Oh, every day I write, and if I don’t, then I am wretched and I make everybody around me miserable. I am naturally scatterbrained, and writing is my way of putting my ducks in a row. Any ducks will do—writing a love poem for my husband or figuring out a plot point or a character trait can satisfy my daily need to make sense of the world. I learned this about myself in college, that I needed to sit quietly, and the forty-plus years of setting aside my mornings to write has been my greatest achievement. Selfishly protecting my mornings has limited my [options] for employment and time [spent] with family and friends. (How lovely it would be to have coffee with a friend at a café!) Depending upon personal urgency, deadlines, and other obligations, I may write for between two and five hours a day. Where do I write? Each of my seven published works of fiction has been written in a particular (different) place. The Spirits was written in the cluttered family house built by my great-grandfather in the shape of a capital H, while sitting in his leather chair at his huge glass-top desk, with my feet on a heating pad—just try heating a sprawling one-story house shaped like an H.

4. What are you reading right now?
Since I’m occupying the family house, I am reading my mother’s journals. In light of all I know now, well, wowza! This young, spirited Susanna had a whole heap of kids and heaps of laundry and dishes and a farm and desires (to be a writer, among others) and no money, only energy. There are small revelations, including this incident when I was twenty-two months old: “Bonnie fell out of her chair and onto her head. She really got hurt—limp and weak—but recovered within an hour or so. Took an over-long nap too.” Ouch! Was that a concussion? Was that what happened to my attention span?

As for properly published books, I just finished Vivian Gornick’s The Situation and the Story: The Art of Personal Narrative (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2002). If you’re thinking about writing a memoir, it’s a good companion book to read alongside Mary Karr’s The Art of Memoir (Harper, 2015). I especially loved Gornick’s distinguishing between personal essay and memoir. 

5. Which author, in your opinion, deserves wider recognition?
I have no idea who gets recognition these days. I thought everybody read Flannery O’Connor, but the young people I’m meeting don’t know her. Often when I’ve just discovered somebody— like in 2023, [when] I discovered Ron Rash, who writes [the] best short stories about rural America—I learn he is already a New York Times and national best-seller. But here I’ll mention the Bulgarian-born Kapka Kassabova. I read Border: A Journey to the Edge of Europe (Graywolf Press, 2017) because somebody gave it to me at Books & Mortar, a store in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and assured me I’d love it. It took me a year to open it up, and in the first chapter, I fell in love with her numinous, mesmerizing prose—so thank you, whoever gave it to me! Kassabova is a Bulgarian poet and travel journalist who lives in the Scottish Highlands. When I recovered from Border, I went on to marvel and cry my way through Anima: A Wild Pastoral (Graywolf Press, 2024). If you want to be enveloped in a matrix woven of humanity and landscape, read her. 

6. What is the biggest impediment to your writing life?
Life is the biggest impediment to my writing life! I love being physically active, and I love to embark on new ventures and adventures. Not to mention, it nearly kills me every single day to sit at my desk long enough to get anything done, especially now that my joints are creaky and sitting makes me ache. Last year I increased the amount of gardening and farming I do, and this summer I sold produce and eggs at the local farmers market. The best part of this is that I got to be at the market socializing with my neighbors and especially with my fascinating husband of thirty-eight years, Christopher. However, it also meant that often I woke up thinking about planting, picking, fertilizing, and internal parasites rather than thinking about my characters and their situations. A few years ago, I read a biography of Edna Ferber, author of the novel Showboat (Doubleday, 1926) and the Pulitzer Prize–winning So Big (Doubleday, 1924). For over a decade she owned a farm in Connecticut. She found it all so compelling that eventually it compromised her productivity as a writer, and so she sold it. 

7. What is one thing that your agent or editor told you during the process of publishing this book that stuck with you?
Jill Bialosky and Bill Clegg advised me wisely in a hundred ways, but my memory is so lousy the particulars don’t stick with me. So did Heidi Bell, my writer friend and copy editor. Bill’s genius was critical upfront in helping me create a novel from the aforementioned short story. As usual, I chose a narrator who was not forthcoming—not only was she cranky but [she was] bottled up emotionally and not able to sort herself out at all. My life’s purpose is to tell difficult stories involving difficult people, but Bill suggested we needed to first establish firm ground from an objective point of view to give the reader a way into Sister Whitby’s experience. “Impossible!” I said. “It can’t be done without violating the point-of-view compact I’m making with the reader!” And then I did it, and it was fun, introducing my reader to the family through the eyes of a more worldly young woman who is keenly curious and observant—precisely the characteristics of my imagined readers! And then it became a new challenge to create a story logic that didn’t require my returning to that initial point of view; to do so would have been to give this well-educated dinner guest too much agency, when the story works to pull the reader ever more deeply into the Whitby family’s world. My reader can decide if I pulled it off.

8. If you could go back in time and talk to the earlier you, before you started The Spirits, what would you say?
Be fearless in taking on this new task! Also, don’t panic or fall into despair when it doesn’t seem to be working. Just keep revising and finding more meaning, the way you always do, and you’ll figure this out. Even if it seems impossible to write a compelling novel about a family mostly sitting at a table, have faith that your compulsion to write it comes from [your conviction about] what matters in this world: Patriarchs must fall, family meals are rich and complicated, landscape informs character. Gosh, now that I’ve spoken my pep talk out loud (on the page), maybe I’ll take it to heart for the next project! Also, I might tell myself not to drink quite so much french press coffee and not to plant the Early Girl variety of tomatoes—they were small and disappointing this year, and they ripened only about a week earlier than the Brandywines, so what was the point? Better to stick to the heirloom varieties.

9. Outside of writing, what other forms of work were essential to the creation of The Spirits?
Well, here I am at the H House, surrounded by family objects, and I’m sitting in my family patriarch’s chair as I write about another kind of patriarchal family! There are lots of projects to distract me around here, a surprising number of them having to do with the aforementioned heating challenges. (We use wood, electric, and oil—I could write a book about it!) The project that has consumed both me and my main character, Sister Whitby, is that of killing invasive species and replacing them with native species in order to support and nourish the local wildlife. My husband and brother and I have felled dozens of 80-foot-tall Norway maple trees as well as trees of heaven, and I spend part of most days taking on bittersweet, garlic mustard, honeysuckle, and black swallow wort. (As I write this, I’m fighting a desire to go out with my bow saw and my bingo marker full of poison and take out a thick bittersweet vine I just discovered under a thicket.)

10. What’s the best piece of writing advice you’ve ever heard?
Oh, gosh, I wish I had a better memory for the particulars by which I live and write! I don’t know what combination of people taught me the writing advice that I give out: Avoid the mystique, just do the work; don’t look for a trick or a gimmick or new way of writing, just do the work; and however and wherever you are able to do the work, that is fine. How good writing happens is mysterious, but the way you get there is to keep working. But if I have to choose one piece of advice that sticks with me, I’ll speak from the family house and defer to my mother, Susanna (RIP), who wrote compelling journals and abhorred the books she considered boring. “Please keep it lively,” she said. This may be easier to do in the adventure and mystery stories my mother preferred to read, in which, say, a woman might steal a bulldozer and run over her ex-husband with it, but it is especially necessary (and very possible) to find that energy and liveliness in a story of people sitting around a dinner table hashing out the past and the future.

Please log in to continue.
LOG IN
Don’t yet have an account?
Register for a free account.