The Nuts and Bolts of Distribution: How Your Book Ends Up in Stores

by
Michael Bourne
From the September/October 2024 issue of
Poets & Writers Magazine

In the minds of many writers, a book’s path to publication ends when they sign off on the final page proofs with an editor and the book is scheduled for printing. After that it vanishes into a mysterious black box marked “book distribution,” only to magically reemerge a few months later on the shelves of a cherished indie bookstore.

In reality, of course, magic has nothing to do with it. Once the final proof leaves the editor’s hands and the book is printed, it enters a dizzyingly complex network of distributors and booksellers, ranging from Amazon to the local independent bookstore to Walmart, that enables publishers to ship their books quickly and efficiently to readers around the world. Largely opaque to those outside the industry, this system drives decisions that publishers make about not only where they will sell their products and to whom, but also how much they can charge for them, how much they can afford to pay their authors, and even what books they acquire and what should go on their covers.

A key player in this network is a company called Ingram Content Group, which after decades of outcompeting and buying up its competitors has emerged as an Amazon of independent book distribution, a corporate giant that serves as a one-stop-shopping outlet for nearly forty thousand retailers and libraries around the world.

The major New York presses known collectively as the Big Five—Penguin Random House, Hachette, HarperCollins, Macmillan, and Simon & Schuster—still maintain their own sales teams and warehouses, and a dwindling number of independent book distribution companies serve presses with sales too low to qualify for distribution with Ingram. But with its six warehouses in the United States, along with print-on-demand plants here and abroad, Ingram provides distribution and sales services directly to roughly 750 publishers and handles printing and warehousing duties for many more, including the Big Five presses themselves.

The distribution system for smaller presses suffered a serious blow in March when the nonprofit Small Press Distribution, or SPD, abruptly shut down, leaving hundreds of presses, many of them specializing in poetry and more experimental work, temporarily without a distributor. An April survey by the Community of Literary Magazines and Presses found that more than a hundred of its member presses were owed money by SPD, ranging from $340 to $40,000, and seventeen presses might ultimately have to shut down due to financial hardship.

The consolidation of book distribution has created a system of astonishing reach and speed that can deliver a book essentially anywhere in the U.S. in four days, and often in just one or two. This, combined with the advent of e-books, audiobooks, and print-on-demand technology that allows publishers to print high-quality copies of their books only when customers order them, has made it possible for anyone with time and an editorial vision to launch a small press.

But this system is expensive, and the ever-rising costs of things writers rarely think about, like paper and warehouse labor, further cut into publishers’ profit margins, particularly at smaller presses, where the costs of printing and distributing a standard paperback can leave a publisher with only a few dollars per copy sold with which to pay staff and royalties to the author.

At a Big Five press, book distribution begins nine months before publication when the press’s sales team meets with editors to hear about a season’s worth of new books in the pipeline, according to Alison Lazarus, who was an executive vice president and sales director at Hachette until she retired late last year. “The editor who acquired each book will talk to the sales force about why they acquired the book, what makes it special, who the reader is,” Lazarus says, “so the sales team can go out with a good understanding of who the customer for the book should be.”

Sales reps then pitch the upcoming season’s slate of books to their accounts, which include indie bookstores, chains, e-tailers, library wholesalers, and buyers of audiobooks like Audible, says Lazarus. These sales meetings, largely invisible to authors, can be essential to the success of a book. Sales reps tip off the retailer’s book buyers about any marketing and publicity plans the publisher may have, take requests for author appearances, and, crucially, recommend how many copies the store should take.

Following these sales meetings, retailers typically order a season’s worth of new books up front because it’s less expensive to order in bulk directly from the publisher’s warehouse than to order from a wholesaler like Ingram, Lazarus says. But when they reorder books, retailers often turn to Ingram because the company’s warehouses stock books from a wide range of presses, and it’s more efficient to aggregate small orders of different titles into one bulk shipment.

“Ingram competes with us as well as supports us,” Lazarus says. “Ingram is an efficient supplier of a broad range of titles to stores, and they’re very fast. They have more warehouses than the publishers do, so sometimes they can get books to a store faster than if they came directly from a publisher.”

This is key to understanding Ingram’s outsize role in the book trade. On the one hand, Ingram is one of the world’s largest book wholesalers, stocking vast quantities of books from different publishers in its warehouses. In this part of its business, Ingram buys print books from publishers at a significant discount and sells the books to retailers and libraries, returing any excess books it cannot sell to the publisher.

Meanwhile, a different branch of the company, called Ingram Publisher Services, or IPS, functions as a full-service book distributor for independent presses. In this part of its business, Ingram offers warehouse and global fulfillment services for smaller presses but also aims to replicate the sales and marketing functions that only larger presses can afford to fund on their own.

“We look at ourselves as if we’re their in-house sales team,” says Meredith Greenhouse, vice president and general manager of IPS. “That’s how closely we work with them. We figure out what a publisher’s expectations are, and then we put marketing behind it. We market to the booksellers; we market directly to consumers. They do the publicity, and we do a lot of the marketing for them.”

These sales and marketing interventions can get quite hands-on. “We’re helping to support the entire publishing process, from acquisition to publication,” Greenhouse says. “We’ll have a publisher say they’re thinking of publishing this kind of book, and they’ll ask us for our opinion on cover direction. We give them sales projections so they print based on what we’re telling them we think this can do in the market. They come in to pitch the books; we tell them if we think the title’s going to work, how the pricing should work, and so on.”

Yet another branch of its business, called IngramSpark, serves self-publishing authors and indie presses, using print-on-demand technology to produce books and, for a fee, deliver them to readers via traditional bookstores or, more often, through purchases made on personal or publisher websites. Still another branch of the business, called Lightning Source, uses this same print-on-demand technology to print books for Big Five and other larger presses looking to print smaller quantities of a certain title or quickly replenish stock of a book that is selling well. And, of course, Ingram can handle e-book and audiobook fulfillment for all its publishing customers.

Despite the size and reach of Ingram’s many branches, Phil Ollila, the company’s chief commercial and content officer, says there’s still plenty of competition for getting books into readers’ hands. “At no other time in book industry history have the barriers to entry for developing a book been lower, and at no other time has access to channels of distribution been more equitable between large, smaller, and self-publishers,” Ollila says. “More books are being published by more publishers, however you define the term, than ever before.”

It is certainly true that self-publishing authors have a wide array of choices, including Amazon’s Kindle Direct Publishing, as well as a growing list of so-called hybrid presses, which claim to share the costs of publishing between author and press. And among more traditional presses, a number of publishers devoted to more adventurous work end up outside the Ingram universe, often because they are too large for IngramSpark but not large enough to attract the interest of Ingram Publisher Services.

Until recently these presses had turned to Small Press Distribution, which used its nonprofit status to keep its fees affordable. But even before its collapse this spring, SPD had a reputation for organizational disarray, and in 2021 the distributor was rocked by allegations of wage theft and other workplace abuses. When it shut down, many of its former clients turned to a Seattle start-up called Asterism, run by a pair of small press publishers, and to Minneapolis-based Itasca Books.

But these smaller distributors don’t offer the same suite of distribution services that larger presses get from Ingram. Asterism, for instance, doesn’t sell to Amazon, preferring to set up its own marketplace on the e-tailer’s website, and offers bookstores the right to return unsold copies only when they hold book events. Itasca, which does sell to Amazon, lacks a dedicated sales team and sells many of its books via Ingram’s warehouses.

For Itasca this access to Ingram is in fact a key element of its allure to its client presses, according to Mark Jung, Itasca’s director of distribution services. While Itasca routinely takes orders directly from stores and from readers clicking Buy buttons on publishers’ websites, it also provides a way for publishers that don’t qualify for Ingram’s full-service distribution services to nevertheless plug into Ingram’s global distribution network, Jung says.

But this comes at a cost. Ingram buys books from Itasca’s client presses at a steep 55 percent discount, Jung says. This means that if an Itasca press sells a book via Ingram for $18, Ingram will take $9.90 from the sale, leaving $8.10 for the press. Out of that remainder, Itasca takes an additional 15 to 20 percent for its role in the transaction, and the press will have to pay for postage, which will eat up another 10 to 12 percent. 

Added to this are the costs of printing the book, which can be handled by Itasca’s partner company, Bookmobile, whose printing plant is next door to the Itasca warehouse. For a run of five hundred paperback copies of a 250-page novel, Bookmobile charges $3.15 per copy, according to Nicole Baxter, the company’s director of sales, marketing, and publisher services.

Therefore, after distribution fees, postage, and print costs, that $18 paperback sold via Ingram will net the press between $2.35 and $2.92—and that’s not counting fees for any books returned by retailers and for warehousing unsold books. Out of that small per-copy return, the press must pay its staff along with its operational costs and, of course, royalties to the author.

The math gets a little better if retailers bypass Ingram and order directly from Itasca and, particularly, if readers order directly from Itasca or a publisher’s website. In the latter case, Jung says, Itasca charges a fee of 30 to 35 percent of the retail price, and the consumer generally pays the postage, meaning that a press may keep roughly $9.45 on the sale of an $18 paperback after distribution fees and printing costs. This helps explain why so many small presses are beefing up their websites and urging readers to order directly from them. (All orders placed on Bookshop, it’s worth noting, are sourced through Ingram.)

These are daunting numbers, and they clearly shape how a small publisher like Arizona-based Noemi Press, which switched to Itasca for its distribution after SPD’s closure, runs its business. Noemi, which publishes a mix of poetry and prose at the more unconventional end of the publishing spectrum, operates as a nonprofit, and its publishing staff are all volunteers, getting paid only when a grant specifically allows for staff payments, according to Sarah Gzemski, the press’s executive director. Noemi doesn’t offer advances, paying its authors royalties on print books only after they’ve sold five hundred copies. (Noemi does pay its authors a 50 percent royalty on all e-book sales.)

“When it comes to how we make the financial side of the press ‘work,’ profits from books aren’t our only source of income,” Gzemski says. “They are the main source, but we do a great deal of grant writing. We also collect fees from our contest each year, receive some sponsorship money, and accept donations from individuals. Book profits are just one piece in the puzzle of how we operate.”

Of course, it’s less expensive to distribute digital copies of books because it avoids the costs of printing, shipping, and stocking a physical object, but these items are typically sold at a lower price and, in the case of audiobooks, require creating an entirely new recorded work. Amazon, which handles roughly 70 percent of Bookmobile’s e-book sales, charges a 55 percent fee for e-books sold on its site, according to Chloe Johnson, digital production and sales coordinator at Bookmobile. In its role as an e-book distributor, Bookmobile takes 20 percent of what’s left over. Thus, an e-book priced at $11.99 will net its publisher $4.32 per copy—hardly a fortune, but significantly more than a press can expect to get on an $18 paperback sold through Ingram.

Given the rising costs of printing and distribution, it’s easy to see why profit margins are so tight across the publishing industry, ranging from essentially nonexistent at a small nonprofit press like Noemi to the high single digits or low double digits for Big Five publishers, depending on the year. And while industry insiders praise Ingram for its speed and efficiency, and say it generally operates as a fair partner to publishers, its dominance of book distribution shows no signs of decreasing. 

“In the last ten years or so, all the little wholesalers have gone away,” says Mark Jung, the Itasca distribution director. “They’ve just evaporated. A lot of that happened during COVID because book sales shriveled and there weren’t any for four or five months.”

“Ingram’s the only game in town these days,” he says.  

 

Michael Bourne is a contributing editor of Poets & Writers Magazine. His debut novel, Blithedale Canyon, was published by Regal House Publishing in 2022.

Thumbnail credit: Tamea Burd

Please log in to continue.
LOG IN
Don’t yet have an account?
Register for a free account.
For access to premium content, become a P&W member today.