| Give a Gift |

  • Digital Edition

Scholars Question Accuracy of Transcribed Frost Notebooks

Daily News

Online Only, posted 1.23.08

Robert Faggen, professor and chairman of the English department at Claremont McKenna College in California, has come under scrutiny for his transcription of Robert Frost's papers collected in The Notebooks of Robert Frost, published by Harvard University Press last January. According to two critics, the compilation of forty-seven of Frost's notebooks contains hundreds of errors.

James Sitar, the archive editor of the Poetry Foundation's Web site, published an article in Essays and Criticism in October 2007 stating that he compared four of Frost's original notebooks, stored in Boston University's archives, to Faggen's work, and found "roughly one thousand" inaccuracies in the transcription.

William Logan, an English professor at University of Florida, also discovered discrepancies while reviewing thirty pages of Frost's notebooks from the Dartmouth archives. In an article forthcoming in Parnassus in March, Logan writes, "To read this volume is to believe that Frost was a dyslexic and deranged speller, that his brisk notes frequently made no sense, that he often traded the expected word for some fanciful or perverse alternative."

The notebooks, which Frost did not intend for publication, are written in a scrawling penmanship obscured further by edits, making the work difficult to decipher. In response to the criticism, Faggen has said, "Any project of this nature and magnitude is bound to invite criticism and undergo changes and improvements, a great many of which have been incorporated into the forthcoming paperback edition," the New York Times reported yesterday.

Harvard University Press is planning to publish several additional collections of Frost's unpublished work, including his letters and lectures, which will be edited and transcribed by Faggen and others.

City Guide

by Jen Michalski

Author Jen Michalski takes us on a tour of the many literary sites writers should visit while strolling the gritty streets of Baltimore.

Upcoming Events
University of Chicago Logan Center, Seminar Terrace 801
October 30, 2014 - 4:30pm
Creative Nonfiction
Wayne State University
October 30, 2014 - 6:00pm
Creative Nonfiction
Encinitas Library
October 30, 2014 - 6:30pm
Lillian Vernon Creative Writers House
October 30, 2014 - 7:00pm
Berl's Poetry Shop
October 30, 2014 - 7:00pm
Conferences & Residencies
Salt Cay, Bahamas
West Cork, Ireland
Riga, Latvia
Writing Contests
Provincetown OuterMost Community Radio
American Library Association
Asheville Poetry Review
Magazine Articles

by Mira Ptacin

November/December 2014

Despite struggles, libraries are learning to navigate the ever-changing, and often cost-prohibitive, landscape of digital lending.


by Staff

Politics & Prose replaces Barnes & Noble as official National Book Festival bookseller; new Berryman volume and reissues released; Carlos Lozada named nonfiction book critic at the Washington Post; and other news.

Directory of Writers
Fiction Writer
Tucson, AZ
Fiction Writer
Oneonta, NY

Subscribe to P&W Magazine | Donate Now | Advertise | Sign up for E-Newsletter | Help | About Us | Contact Us | View Mobile Site

© Copyright Poets & Writers 2014. All Rights Reserved