| Give a Gift |

  • Digital Edition

The "Ethics in Book Reviewing" Panel: Postcard From New York City, Part 2


Online Only, posted 6.06.07

Oh that mine enemy were to write a book.

It's a line, paraphrased from the Book of Job, that was uttered last Friday morning at BookExpo America by Christopher Hitchens—author of the recently published book God Is Not Great—as the motto from his earlier book reviewing days. It was an odd sentiment to be heard at a panel called "Ethics in Book Reviewing: The More Things Change…?" but it certainly made the crowd, which was packed in and spilling out of the conference room, laugh out loud. And it set the tone for the rest of the panelists' comments.

Not everyone talked about how they wished they could review their enemies' books, but the panelists, which included Carlin Romano from the Philadelphia Inquirer and David L. Ulin from the Los Angeles Times, did talk about how and why it is possible to review books by friends and colleagues and still, as they say, stay within unwritten ethical boundaries and produce fair reviews. They also talked about why it’s nearly impossible to not write about people you know.

"Who else am I supposed to be friends with? I’ve been in this business forty years," said John Leonard of Harper's Magazine, who suggested that it’s sometimes better to review someone you know. "Who knows them better? I know every word."

Author Francine Prose and Sam Tanenhaus, editor of the New York Times Book Review, spoke of the relationship between author and reviewer not as a two-way conversation, but as a service to readers. "What we look at first is the reader," said Tanenhaus.

"The most unethical thing is to write a boring review," said Prose.

One might not expect ethics to be such a big draw at a book publishing convention, but the event was heavily promoted by the National Book Critics Circle as a venue for talking about the shrinking space given to book reviews in American newspapers. The conversation stayed on the topic of ethics, however, with Hitchens and Leonard sharing anecdotes about writing enemies and friends, book review disasters, and war stories from the book review trenches.

"Ethics in book reviews is such small potatoes compared to corruption in culture at large," said Leonard. "And there’s no money in it anyway."

Article Permissions
The "Ethics in Book Reviewing" Panel: Postcard From New York City, Part 2

In the details box below, please include information about the reprint permissions you'd like granted.

Thank you for your permissions request. We do our best to respond immediately, but it may take up to three business days.

City Guide

by T Cooper

From newly established bookstores such as McNally Jackson Books in SoHo to long-time forums such as the Poetry Project at St. Mark’s Church on the Lower East Side, T Cooper, author, most recently, of The Beaufort Diaries, visits his favorite places to research, revise, and read in New York City.

Upcoming Events
Donaghy Theatre
October 30, 2014 - 7:30pm
Poetry/Fiction/Creative Nonfiction
Centre for Social Innovation
November 1, 2014 - 10:00am
Bowery Poetry Club
November 2, 2014 - 2:00pm
Poetry/Fiction/Creative Nonfiction
Midtown West
November 5, 2014 (All day)
The New School's Orozco Room
November 6, 2014 - 6:30pm
Conferences & Residencies
New York, New York United States
New York City, New York United States
New York, New York United States
Writing Contests
Poetry Society of America
Bronx Council on the Arts
Magazine Articles

by Rebecca Bates

November/December 2014

The Center for Humanities at the CUNY Graduate Center in New York City is making the ephemeral more tangible through its Lost & Found chapbook series.

by Cat Richardson

November/December 2014

The New York City–based art and politics magazine rings in its second decade with its first paid staff position and the launch of a print anthology.

by Julia Fierro

September/October 2014

Founder of the Sackett Street Writers' Workshop in Brooklyn, New York, Julia Fierro discusses how creating her own workshop program—and in doing so, building her own community of writers—allowed her to rediscover her own voice.

Directory of Writers
Ridgewood, Queens, NY
Fiction Writer
New York, NY
Glen Ridge, NJ

Subscribe to P&W Magazine | Donate Now | Advertise | Sign up for E-Newsletter | Help | About Us | Contact Us | View Mobile Site

© Copyright Poets & Writers 2014. All Rights Reserved