»

| Give a Gift |

  • Digital Edition

Court Considers Appeal in Salinger Suit

Daily News

Online Only, posted 9.08.09

A court in New York City is considering whether the U.S. publication of Fredrik Colting’s 60 Years Later: Coming Through the Rye, originally billed as an “unauthorized sequel” to The Catcher in the Rye, could cause irreparable harm to author J. D. Salinger. During oral arguments at the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday, two members of the three-judge panel questioned whether a lower court had collected enough evidence before issuing a preliminary injunction against Colting in July.

“This case is about banning a book,” Edward Rosenthal, lead counsel for Colting, told the appeals court. Rosenthal reiterated arguments that 60 Years Later, which Colting published this summer in Sweden and the U.K. under the pseudonym J. D. California, deserved protection under the “fair use” provisions extended to criticism and parody. “Our position is this is not a sequel,” he said. “This is a highly transformative work about the relationship between Salinger and his character.” Colting’s appeal, filed in July, also contests the injunction on the grounds that it constitutes prior restraint of speech and presumes harm to Salinger before evidence of actual harm.

Marcia Paul, lead counsel for Salinger, argued that preemptive enjoinment was necessary to protect the integrity of her client’s intellectual property, something ex post facto monetary damages could not achieve. “You can’t put the genie back in the bottle,” Paul told the court.

Thursday’s hearing also touched upon the online availability of the contested spin-off. Judge Guido Calabresi called 60 Years Later a “rather dismal piece of work,” but questioned the effectiveness of barring a book which had already been published—without challenge—in Europe. “Anybody can just go on the Internet and get the London edition,” he said.

Amicus briefs have been filed in support of Colting’s right to publish by several library, free speech, and media groups, including the Associated Press, Gannett, the Tribune Company, and the New York Times. If the preliminary injunction is vacated, the famously reclusive Salinger could be forced to testify or risk having his suit dismissed.

The court did not say when it would rule.

Reader Comments

City Guide

by Jen Michalski

Author Jen Michalski takes us on a tour of the many literary sites writers should visit while strolling the gritty streets of Baltimore.

Upcoming Events
Fiction
Panel
Marriott Hotel at the Convention Center
October 31, 2014 - 2:00pm
Poetry
Reading
Antigone Books
October 31, 2014 - 7:00pm
Poetry
Reading/Workshop/Talk/Performance
Walt Whitman Walt Whitman Birthplace State Historic Site and Interpretive Center
November 1, 2014 (All day)
Poetry
Workshop
Hilton Garden Inn
November 1, 2014 - 9:30am
Fiction
Workshop
Writespace Houston
November 1, 2014 - 10:00am
Conferences & Residencies
Conference
Salt Cay, Bahamas
Residency
West Cork, Ireland
Residency
Riga, Latvia
Writing Contests
Provincetown OuterMost Community Radio
American Library Association
Asheville Poetry Review
Magazine Articles

by Staff

November/December 2014

Artist and architect Matteo Pericoli pairs drawings of views from the desks of writers around the world with essays by those writers about where they write, what they see, and how their view informs their work

by Mira Ptacin

November/December 2014

Despite struggles, libraries are learning to navigate the ever-changing, and often cost-prohibitive, landscape of digital lending.

 

Directory of Writers
Poet
Naperville, IL
Poet, Fiction Writer
Katonah, NY

Subscribe to P&W Magazine | Donate Now | Advertise | Sign up for E-Newsletter | Help | About Us | Contact Us | View Mobile Site

© Copyright Poets & Writers 2014. All Rights Reserved