Cutting Out the Middleman: How Substack Connects Writers to Readers, and What That Means for Legacy Publishing

by
Katie Arnold-Ratliff
From the November/December 2026 issue of
Poets & Writers Magazine

Publishing one’s work in the traditional manner often drop-kicks a writer into a dispiriting dichotomy: All the creative liberty and autonomy of idea generating and headlong drafting and careful tinkering abruptly morphs. In the publishing stage, writing becomes a joint venture. Someone who has been offered a book deal or a magazine assignment or a contract for a short story or poem is, to put it crassly, beholden to the entity forking out the cash, as well as any demands that may be attached to the forking: a house style, a word count, a news peg, darlings to kill. That’s if you’re lucky enough to ink a deal at all. For many, writing is delicious; it’s the process of publishing that often leaves a bitter taste in the mouth. 

Of course that all changes if one finds a way around the rigmarole. For many years that meant self-publishing, or blogging, or printing zines at Kinko’s. But when Substack arrived in 2017 it formalized this end run around the classic system, giving writers a user-friendly, monetizable way to usher unfiltered work into the world. Now with Substack you create a free account, write what you like, and post it whenever you feel like it—also for free. You can charge for subscriptions or not. There are all kinds of ways to attract readers, but it helps if you’re active on the site’s Notes area, a kind of running feed of brief thoughts akin to social media. The end product has the veneer of professionalism, legitimacy—a significant step up from the blogs of yore.

Sari Botton, the author of the memoir And You May Find Yourself…: Confessions of a Late-Blooming Gen X Weirdo (Heliotrope Books, 2022), publishes two digital magazines on Substack: Oldster, about the experience of aging, and Memoir Land, in which writers share personal narratives. Releasing her publications this way, Botton says, “has allowed me to have a kind of editorial expansiveness I could never have even imagined in my many years as both a staffer and freelancer for legacy media.” Her publications—which have drawn over eighty-six thousand and thirty-six thousand subscribers, respectively—tend to be more nuanced, interior, and immediate than the work one might find in those legacy publications; without Substack and its liberties, the world likely would never read them. Now no gatekeepers stand in Botton’s way. “I no longer have to chase editors,” she says, “or wait in line for them to consider me and offer me limited opportunities, which often would include editing my work in a way I was unhappy with, or killing it at the eleventh hour because of some whim.” Botton’s magazines, which charge subscribers $50 to $55 per year or $5 or $6 per month, are a financial success as well: “I get to publish my own writing and the writing of others I admire, and it is both a joy and a way in which I’m able to support myself.” 

Sometimes the role of the most powerful literary gatekeepers is to keep out all things weird or niche, leaving room for only the most broadly palatable (and commercially promising) material. But esotericism is alive and well on Substack, according to novelist Garth Greenwell, the author of Small Rain (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2024) and Cleanness (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2020). His own newsletter, To a Green Thought, is a hodgepodge of “whatever’s obsessing me at a particular moment,” he says, and the topics can vary widely. “The main benefit of Substack,” he adds, “is that it’s a place to publish pieces no magazine would touch: five thousand words on a painting by Édouard Vuillard, say, or a close reading of Alice Rohrwacher’s 2011 film, Corpo Celeste.” Who cares if that movie came out fifteen years ago? Greenwell loves that he can write what he likes, “without having to find some artificial topical hook.” Ironically, the readers who followed Greenwell off-piste and onto Substack are most likely those same readers who came to know him from his novels, raising the question of whether one still needs a published book before Substack can be a going concern.

Catherine Newman, the author most recently of the novel Sandwich (Harper, 2024), like Botton, is a magazine veteran who relishes the leeway of writing without an editor—as a seasoned pro, she’s happy to skip “somebody’s ten-year-old son boysplaining writing to me,” as she puts it. Newman refuses to paywall her popular middle-age-focused Substack, Crone Sandwich, because she feels this keeps it undiluted by outside influence. “I don’t want there to be shareholders,” she says. This decision was influenced by her son, a former math and economics major. “He was like, ‘Your net happiness will be higher if you don’t charge, even if you end up making less money,’” Newman recalls. “He was right.” (While Newman has a fee structure set up for her Substack, none of her posts are actually subscriber-only. Still, many readers opt to pay for the content out of sheer appreciation for her work.) 

Even if what you’re looking to put out into the world isn’t all that esoteric, it still may lack a natural home in the traditional publishing world. “I don’t know who else would let me write the kind of stuff I’m writing and publish the kind of stuff I’m publishing,” says thriller writer Andrea Bartz, whose recent thriller is The Last Ferry Out (Ballantine Books, 2025). (You may also recognize her name from the recent lawsuit against an AI giant, Bartz v. Anthropic.) Her Substack, Get It Write, is “a publication for current and prepublication authors, especially novelists interested in traditional publishing.” It is indeed difficult to imagine many print magazines that could offer the space where Bartz could go into such minute detail about this world—Get It Write features everything from Q&As with booksellers to personal essays about writers’ experiences to thorough breakdowns of how much Bartz earns from her deals. She also appreciates the platform’s freedom from so-called shadowbanning. “On social media the algorithm will quietly sunset you or stop showing you to followers if it doesn’t like what you’re doing,” she says. (Like, say, discussing sensitive or politically charged issues, which many writers do, or accidentally using a banned hashtag, or doing some other seemingly innocuous thing you don’t even realize is a problem.) “But on Substack,” Bartz continues, “people give me their emails, and it shows up in their inbox without an algorithm in between.”

Like Bartz, Rebecca Makkai, the author of the novels I Have Some Questions for You (Viking, 2023) and The Great Believers (Viking, 2018), likes to use the platform to reach not just fellow readers, but fellow writers too. She publishes SubMakk—a catalogue, its description reads, of “general inanity” that also often delves into the craft of writing. “Former students and colleagues would often write to me for handouts I’d used in a class,” says Makkai, “and I discovered that I could expand them and make them publicly available through Substack. I’ve also found that I can refer new students to older posts—so, for example, if someone is struggling with character interiority, I can send them the link to what I wrote on the subject.” If none of that sounds like inanity, don’t worry: “It’s also a great place to post silly things, and I regularly post ridiculous Zillow finds,” Makkai says. “But helping people access good writing instruction is a key part of it for me.” While many literary publications would surely be happy to publish a best-selling novelist’s writing advice, putting it into the world oneself is far simpler than the pitching-to-editing-to-revising pipeline.

Although much has been noted about the income that writers can generate on Substack, the folks interviewed for this article barely mentioned money. While Botton’s publications have led to other opportunities (a New York Times profile, an anthology now in the works), and Newman is moved by her voluntary paid subscribers, these Substackers appear to be more excited about something else: creative freedom, unmitigated by an editor or publisher or past sales figures. Or even, truth be told, by the possibility that a reader might not be interested in the topic of the day. “It’s mine, all mine,” says Newman about her Substack. “I can write about whatever I want, as frequently or infrequently as I like, and if you don’t like it, you can stop reading or unsubscribe.” 

Unless you happen to helm a magazine or run an imprint, that level of freedom does not, cannot, exist in legacy media—and frankly not even then, because here come a cadre of copy wonks and market mavens and ad salespeople to keep you in line. But with great freedom comes great responsibility, and doing it all yourself also has its costs: Rare is the Substack author with a proofreader to ensure immaculate copy, a fact-checker to sort truthiness from truth, an editor to converse with and make that author’s ideas richer, deeper, expressed at their best. And there’s also the issue of its ephemerality: A digital text can’t linger like those glossy mags on a coffee table or the books you turn to again and again. Substack may never fully replace traditional publishing—not until writers can make as much money on the platform as they would selling work to publishers—but it’s certainly already eating some of its lunch, shifting countless stories and ideas and nuggets of intellectual property away from its pages, both paper and web. When you make the barrier to entry as lofty, and the hoop-jumping as onerous, as it has always been in this industry, you practically dare the market to correct itself by generating easier, more accessible options. It seems we’ve reached that point in the timeline.  

 

Katie Arnold-Ratliff is a freelance journalist and editor and the author of the novel Bright Before Us (Tin House Books, 2011).

Thumbnail credit: Dori Flynn
 
 

Please log in to continue.
LOG IN
Don’t yet have an account?
Register for a free account.
For access to premium content, become a P&W member today.